The short answer: When a job posting won’t list pay, ask three questions before you apply. What does the role pay in this market? Why did this posting leave the number out? Does that answer change how you read the offer? In one 2026 survey, 44 percent of recent applicants said they’re unlikely to apply without a range.
This applies to anyone weighing a job where the pay isn’t posted; we cover it from the job seeker’s side, with trades and manufacturing roles among the examples.
Forty-four percent of recent job applicants say they’re unlikely to apply for a job that doesn’t list a pay range. That comes from a Patriot Software survey of 1,000 people who applied for jobs in the past year. In the same survey, 84 percent said they believe companies hide pay to limit how much workers can negotiate. Yet a job posting pay range is still optional across most of the country, Montana included. So the work of finding the number lands on the person applying. That is the wrong way around.
On LC Staffing’s own LinkedIn page, posts built on Montana workforce data drew the most engagement in each 30-day period we measured from mid-July through September. In August 2026, two such posts drew more than half of all engagement across our LinkedIn and Instagram pages, from about a tenth of what we published. Local data is what our readers respond to. This guide puts it to work on one question.
This guide covers why so many postings still skip the range and the three questions that get you the number. It then covers how to read the reply, when to ask, and the three numbers to hold before you accept. The wage figures are public state and federal data.
Why Do Job Postings Leave Out the Pay Range?
Many postings skip pay simply because nothing requires them to show it. As of August 2026, 13 states and Washington, D.C. required pay information in job postings, per Paychex’s state-by-state tracker. Montana was not one of them. A blank can be habit or a choice, and the posting won’t say which.
Where a law does exist, postings change. New York’s posting law took effect in September 2023, and a year later 97.7 percent of New York postings on Indeed carried pay information, per Indeed’s Hiring Lab. Nationally, the share stood at 59 percent by May 2025, according to Indeed’s 2025 pay transparency release. New York has a law; most states don’t.
Manufacturing has been among the slowest to move. In Hiring Lab’s 2024 review, production and manufacturing postings showed the smallest gain of any occupational sector it tracked: 0.2 percentage points between September 2023 and September 2024. That is a small move.
None of that means the employer is hiding something. It means you can’t read intent from a blank. You need to ask.
Check the last three jobs you applied for: which listed pay up front? Those employers answered question one for you. The rest asked you to apply on trust, so the number is still yours to find. Weighing one? Compare notes with us
How Do You Find Out What a Job Pays Before You Apply?
Ask three questions before you invest another hour. What does the role pay here? Why did the posting leave the number out? Does the answer change your read of the offer? In May 2025, Montana’s median pay for all jobs ran from $22.36 to $26.46 an hour across five metro areas. Start with your own area.
1. What does this role pay in this market?
National salary sites average across very different places, and that blurs the one number you need. Montana publishes its own. In the state’s informational wage rates from the Montana Department of Labor and Industry, find your occupation first. Then read the line for your metro area or region, not the all-jobs line. Area alone moves the number. In the May 2025 estimates, the median for all jobs was $55,040 a year around Helena and $46,510 around Great Falls. That is $8,530 a year inside one state. Our Montana salary expectations piece shows how pay has moved in the skilled trades.
2. Why did this posting leave the number out?
Ask it plainly and early: “What’s the pay range for this role?” Then ask why it isn’t on the posting. You are not being difficult. In the Patriot survey, 45 percent of applicants described leaving pay off a posting as disrespectful. Plenty of people want the same answer you do.
3. Does the answer change how you read the offer?
Write the range down the moment you hear it, with the date and the name of the person who said it. When an offer arrives, set it next to that note. If you are weighing work across a state line, compare like with like. Our Montana vs. Idaho benchmarks show how far one role can drift.
A Straight Answer, a Dodge, or a Shrug: Reading the Reply
Treat the reply to “why isn’t pay posted?” as a lead, not a verdict. A plain range, an “it depends,” a “later,” and an “I’m not sure” each call for a different follow-up. With 84 percent of applicants suspicious of hidden pay, a straight answer is worth noting. A vague one is worth one more question.
The table below pairs the four replies you’re most likely to hear with what each might mean and the follow-up to ask.
| The reply | What it might mean | What to ask next |
| A range, stated plainly | The role may already be budgeted | Is that the range for my level? |
| “It depends on experience” | Pay may be banded by level | What’s the range at my level? |
| “We’ll cover that later” | Pay may be settled at the offer | Can you share a range now? |
| “I’m not sure” | Pay may not be set yet | Who sets it, and when? |
Every follow-up does the same job. It moves a number onto the table before you spend more time on the process. If a second ask still gets no range, that is information too, and you can weigh it against the other jobs on your list.
A useful move is asking for the range in writing before a second interview. An email that says “Just confirming the range we discussed” costs nothing. It turns a conversation into a record, and records are harder to walk back.
When in the Hiring Process to Ask About Pay
Ask at three points: before you apply, at the first screening call, and before you accept. Montana ended 2025 with about 1.1 job openings per unemployed person, per the state’s 2026 Labor Day Report, down from more than three in 2022. With fewer openings per seeker, a posting that won’t say what it pays is worth qualifying early.
- Before you apply. If the posting lists a phone number or a recruiter, ask for the range in one short message.
- At the first screening call. Ask for the range at your level of experience, not the whole band. Write it down before the call ends.
- Before you accept. Confirm the number, the schedule and the start date in writing. An offer you can’t see on paper isn’t finished.
Set a reminder for each point if it helps. Ask the question yourself, in your own words, because the tone of the reply is part of the answer. A recruiter can ask on your behalf, too; our piece on how recruiters help explains how that works in practice.
Three Numbers to Write Down Before You Accept
Before you accept, write down three numbers: the median for your occupation in your area, the range the employer gave you, and the offer itself. Even nationally, only 59 percent of postings on Indeed showed pay in May 2025, so the range you were told may be the only one you get. Read the three together.
Each number answers a different question. The local median tells you what the market pays for your kind of work. The range tells you what this employer planned to pay. The offer tells you what they decided you’re worth. Each alone can mislead.
Read them in combination. Say you’re a welder with an offer in hand. Find the median for welders in your area first. If your area’s row has no figure, use the regional or statewide line. If the employer’s range sits below the median, the role may be priced low for that market, or set for less experience than yours. Ask what level it assumes. If the offer sits below the range you were given, raise the difference before you sign. If both sit at or above your occupation’s median, push on schedule, training and start date instead.
Write the median down before your first call, not after the offer. A number you looked up after hearing theirs tends to drift toward theirs. If you are new to the field, our guide to finding manufacturing work covers where to start.
One applicant in six offered a job with a posted range says the final offer came in below it. Before signing, set your range beside the offer. An unexplained shortfall is money you can still ask about. Numbers don’t match? Talk it through
Frequently Asked Questions
Get the Number Before You Need It
Forty-four percent of recent applicants say they’re unlikely to apply to a posting with no pay range, and 13 states plus Washington, D.C. now make employers post one. Median pay for all jobs ran from $22.36 to $26.46 an hour across five Montana metro areas in May 2025. Three questions and three numbers tell you where an offer sits.
The decision, the negotiation and the yes are yours. Matching people with roles across the region, and helping candidates negotiate pay when an offer comes through us, is part of what LC Staffing’s recruiters do every day. When you’re ready to look at roles, search current openings and ask for the range on the first call.
References
- [“44% Won’t Apply Without Pay Transparency: What Job Seekers Expect in 2026 [Survey].”](https://www.patriotsoftware.com/blog/payroll/pay-transparency-hiring-survey/) Patriot Software. Published February 10, 2026. Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “Pay Transparency Laws by State.” Paychex. Published September 15, 2026 (last updated). Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “Salary Transparency Growth Slows, but Momentum Continues.” Indeed Hiring Lab. Published October 23, 2024 (historic, September 2024 data). Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “Pay Transparency Across High-Earning Sectors.” Indeed. Published July 2, 2025. Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “Informational Wage Rates by Occupation, 2025.” Montana Department of Labor and Industry (May 2025 Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics estimates). Published July 2026. Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “2026 Montana Labor Day Report.” Montana Department of Labor and Industry. Published September 2026. Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “SB 313: Revise laws relating to wage transparency.” Montana Free Press Capitol Tracker, compiling Montana Legislature records. Published May 23, 2025 (last recorded action). Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “SB 313, introduced bill text.” Montana Legislature, via Montana Free Press Capitol Tracker. Published February 13, 2025. Verified live 2026-10-13.
- “Your Rights.” National Labor Relations Board. Published undated. Verified live 2026-10-13.